TootFeed
@RaphaelWimmer @stevel @jaseg @tonofcrates @jsquare I really would want some more transparency here, would y'all consider boosting my other post addressed at SIGCHI itself, for a bit more publicity? -> https://hci.social/@floe/117166670130919695
@RaphaelWimmer @stevel @jaseg @tonofcrates @jsquare oh I'm sure that OpenAI and Anthropic promise to keep any uploaded material confidential ✌️🤞
Hey @sigchi ! I've only now read about the new "Assisted Desk Rejects" for @chi 2027 (via @tonofcrates ), and I _really_ think this process needs some more transparency: would you please make public a) the "rubric" or prompt, and b) which specific LLM you're using for the process?
@stevel @jaseg @RaphaelWimmer @tonofcrates I don't think they actually trained their own LLM - they have their "rubric", which I guess is basically an extended prompt, and bolted that onto one of the current frontier models?
@jaseg @RaphaelWimmer @tonofcrates Absolutely! What I would really like to do, given the model and prompt, is to run some papers from previous years through the pipeline (maybe 3 times each) and collect some data on how they would fare ...
@RaphaelWimmer @tonofcrates Agreed - I understand the motivation, but the process is completely opaque.
From TFA: "To help ACs manage the volume, an AI-assisted tool will assess the paper against a rubric based on ACM criteria (Originality, Correctness, Novelty, Importance, and Clarity of Exposition) to produce a preliminary report for each paper."
At the very least, I would want to know which exact LLM they are using and what the prompt is, otherwise, they might just as well flip a coin. 😑
@datarama that's a difficult one. I think it mostly depends on the water depth. 🦈🐊
@inawhilecrocodile absolutely, my students had the same idea a couple of years ago: https://scholar.google.com/citations?view_op=view_citation&hl=en&user=sZssYagAAAAJ&cstart=20&pagesize=80&sortby=pubdate&citation_for_view=sZssYagAAAAJ:1sJd4Hv_s6UC
Sadly, this never went anywhere further, project-wise 🤷
@dat keep an eye on the dumpster 😉
@dat don't throw it out - the Samsung panel is a very unique piece of hardware, they actually had a dedicated LCD fabrication line only for this model. And with Linux, it's still quite useable.
If one of you nerds in northern Germany or maybe southern Denmark wants a HUGE touchscreen for 300 bucks, there's a working Samsung SUR40 (aka Microsoft Pixelsense) for sale in Lower Saxony: https://www.ebay.de/itm/158218959099
Hit me up if you want to install Linux, I wrote the kernel driver for the touchscreen together with @mkalten 😁
(beware: pickup only, it's 37 kg and nearly impossible to carry alone, I know this from firsthand experience 😖)
@anneroth hmm, wo könnte man diese Datenbank wohl finden... 🤔
@jwildeboer The stove in our new house inexplicably has WiFi. That's staying disconnected for sure 😬
@tubetime No, wait, even better: 3-phase power! I mean, it obviously has 3 phases and ground, right? 😬
@tubetime you just _know_ that someone, somewhere is running 220 V over that thing 🫣
@rygorous @regehr ah neat, if you look closely, you can see a bit of the time multiplexing going on in the yellow text (b/c rolling camera shutter)
@billgoats niiice, including the ancient sigil of the Bundespost 👍
Free product idea: high-speed adjustable desk for extra productivity, no more waiting 30 seconds for the new position with 12 g acceleration! 💪
(some anchoring required)
@scanlime without the context of the previous post, the second one had me _very_ confused at first 🤔
@datatrash @cwebber They had me at "human-led process". 😑